We've
complained before about a hole in available late 80s/early 90s
material, an unfortunate situation which seems to be the result of the
time period in question being too young for nostalgic reissues, but too
old for much of the less (financially) successful efforts to still be
in print. Rosa Luxemburg is one example of a legendary band who rarely
darken the shelves of Tokyo's (shrinking, but still numerous) record
stores; Papaya Paranoia is another. We successfully tracked down main
Papaya Yumiko Ishijima, but finding the woman herself has proven to be
easier than finding her pre-90s work. Fortunately, the band's first two
albums, Mohaya Kore Made and War War War, have finally been reissued as
one double disc package. Taken together, they're a revelation, a wealth
of bizarre, spastic 80s pop at its most over excited and fried.
The all female Papaya Paranoia's approach to the often caustic, but
ultimately liberating energy of New Wave stands in stark contrast to
the confrontational deconstructions of other female New Wave icons,
like The Slits, or Lydia Lunch. Ishijima consciously chose to embrace traditional
femininity (and by traditional, I mean traditional: Mohaya Kore Made
sees the four piece in kimonos.) In her acceptance of the constraints
of standard expectations concerning appearance, she consumed them,
resulting in a mind bending disconnect between the flashy, mainstream
cuteness of the members and the jagged, utterly warped, and thoroughly
unladylike sounds they made.
The importance of that particular decision shouldn't be overstated, as
what ultimately made Papaya Paranoia so compelling was their musical
dynamism. We reviewed Mohaya Kore Made (i.e. We've Had Enough)
previously, and yeah, it's still pretty damned out there; the steely,
arrogant guitar bomb that opens "ゴーゴンズ" ("Gorgons") still draws blood,
and Ishijima's powerful but aggressively off kilter vocals are still
remarkable, taking the atonal warble of early Siouxsie Sioux and
somehow making it sound technically accomplished and from-the-gut
powerful. The snotty grit of "Gorgons" is abandoned immediately, going
straight into "夏が終わる" ("Natsu Ga Owaru," i.e. "The End Of Summer,") an
ambient, chilly drift. The ideas are all over the place;
"鬼の好物アニマルプリント", ("Oni No Koubutsu Animal Print," i.e. "The Demon's
Favorite Animal Print") is like a Girl Scout meeting gone horribly
wrong, "わがままな肉食" ("Wagamama Na Nikushoku," i.e. "Selfish Predator") is
a funhouse crawl, and "貴婦人の散歩" ("Kifujin No Sanpo," i.e. "A Walking
Lady") sounds like Lene Lovich and Klaus Nomi had a particularly
hyperactive baby.
The musicianship in general is top notch, but special mention should be
made of guitarist Maki, who takes 80s glam metal chops and makes them
actually sound as utterly filthy and completely debased as the poodle
metal guys thought they were (wisely, she's mixed way, way up front,
which just emphasizes how in your face her playing really is.)
Similarly, the dual keyboards of Mieya and Harry (just first names
here) make no attempt to color the background, instead charging forward
and splattering everything with gleefully obnoxious blurts of noise
that nonetheless retain their tunefulness.
The incessant gear shifts can make Mohaya Kore Made feel schizophrenic,
but the ideas are fleshed out well enough that it's difficult to fault
the band for their ambition. Still, there are times it can seem a bit
too much; it's difficult to tell what, exactly, holds Mohaya Kore Made
together, but whatever it is, it's hanging on by its fingernails.
War War War, the followup, balances the carnival smirk and heavy rock
punch in a considerably more coherent package. The album saw the
addition of second guitarist Miho, and the extra heft makes the title
track hit like a ton of bricks, taking the paranoid, flattened funk of
Flipper and loading it up with heavy metal chug and corrosive keyboards
that sound like the most malignant funhouse ever. The one-two punch of
"A・X・I・A" and "踊らにゃソン!" ("Odoranya Song") take punk pogo and paint a nightmarish clown
smile on its evil, sweaty face. "20世紀の子供達" (Niju Seki No Kodomotachi,"
i.e. "Children Of The 20th Century") is Oingo Boingo with less Louis
Prima, more crystal meth.
The meatier rock punch easily compensates for the reduced dynamics, but
while War War War is less sprawling, it's still got quite a bit of
space between its extremes. The neon Laurie Anderson glow of "Swimming
In The Pool" and the psychedelic lullaby of "太古のエメラルド" ("Taiko No
Emerald", i.e. "Ancient Emerald") fit in, rather than willfully
disrupt, the album's flow. That said, it's difficult to proclaim War
War War superior to Moyaha Kore Made; better to say it's more focused,
and leave it at that. This package adds eleven bonus tracks, all culled
from singles and one offs from the period. Wisely, they're mostly
appended to the Moyaha Kore Made disc, letting War War War mostly stand
on its own. Papaya Paranoia's early appeal, atonal as it could be, was
still ultimately a pop based aesthetic, which means that these
individual tracks don't come off as afterthoughts; each works as its
own self contained idea. Even with two demos, none of the extras feel
slight or unnecessary; the (relatively) restrained "眠れない夜のために"
("Nemurenai Yoru No Tame Ni," i.e. "For A Sleepless Night) in
particular is a tasty blend of relaxed verses, wired choruses, and
dreamy asides.
In this period, Papaya Paranoia put out one more EP (Lunatic) and
started getting major label attention. Unfortunately, the bright lights
scared off everyone but Ishijima, resulting her one solo album
(Babuhaja) and no new Papaya Paranoia material until 1997's Vanilla
Moon. It would have been nice to see Lunatic on here; it would have
made this issue a complete picture of the band in its first, most manic
incarnation (although in all fairness, the disc is subtitled "The
Captain Years," and Captain Records didn't do Lunatic.) But complete or
no, these two discs make a strong argument
for Papaya Paranoia being one of the great lost (to the West) bands of
the 80s.